Monday, 16 July 2012

All Muck, No Medals by Joan Mant ~ review

I'm reading...

The Women's Land Army was actually founded in 1917, but it was during the Second World War that this organisation attracted the kind of attention which assured its place in the annals of the British war effort. Joan Mant's engaging account of what life was like working in the Women's Land Army clearly shows what a hard and demanding task these women had; a task that lacked the apparent glamour of life in the armed services. The book's accounts show the harsh reality of what these women went through, from eating raw potatoes, starting work at 4am and having to bathe in milk sterilisers. Despite the hardships these women faced they are still able to provide moving accounts of their lives which reflect a common sense of humour, camaraderie and pride. All Muck, No Medals is a fitting tribute to the WLA's heroic effort to keep food on the nation's table and establishes their well-earned place in the archives of the Second World War.

I do like a good book about my favourite service women from World War II -  and this book delivers it in spades (along side hoes, tractors, milk pales & rat catching)

I have read a lot of first hand accounts of the Womens Land Army (WLA) over the past few of years. Some of these have been written by family members after an elderly mother or grandmother has dictated her memories and published independantly. They are a joy to read and there are some coming up for review.

But this book has grabbed a whole load of these memories in the 1990's and handily put them all in one place. Well done that author -  who was also a Land Girl.

The book is interspursed with memories of the author and the countless former Land Girls who replied to an advert Joan Mant placed.

All angles are covered, from why these young women decided to join the WLA -  with reasons ranging from "I liked the thought of the outdoors" to "The WRENS were not recruiting", training, pay, animal woes, aching limbs and laughing their way through the agony of being away from home for the first time.

I feel that I really learnt a lot from this anthology including anger inducing recollections of Land Girls being made to work in desperate weather whilst conscientious objectors and POW's were sent back to base, the WLA not being recognised as a service uniform and so use of subsidised NAFFI vans became unreachable and pay being heavily docked by farmers until complaints were made and the young woman moved on.

There is also tales of real camaraderie, dances and tinned peaches with American & Canadian soldiers and feeding orphaned lambs by bottle in front of the kitchen fire.

I think that this is a book that I shall refer back to time and again. In 2009 it was republished under the title of "All Muck, Now Medals" after the long awaited introduction of service medals for former WLA members in 2007.

For me, this is a definitive collection of memories of the so very often Forgotten Army.



  1. I'll put this one on my amazon wish list...which is already very long! looks interesting. It makes me rage the way these women were treated, so bloody unfair.

  2. Sounds very interesting! Will def have to put it on my amazon wishlist! xox

  3. Thanks for sharing another great book.... off to add it to my wish list :) x

  4. Ooh, sounds fascinating. I'll have to get myself a copy.

    Nikki x

  5. Looks like a great book.I will see if I can get a copy.I have been watching movies about land girls lately.They sure worked hard.xx


I'd love to hear what you think so feel free to comment away!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...